During the tribal phase of the game, the tribes vie for the ownership of the Immunity Idol. The winning tribe will be granted safety from the upcoming Tribal Council. In rare cases, there are double eliminations and both tribes go to Tribal Council, where the Immunity Idol temporarily retires and is replaced with the Immunity Necklace which is usually only available post-merge. But after the double boot twist, the idol returns until the merger.
| Rank | Tribe | Wins | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ni'ihau | 10 | Hawaii |
| O'ahu | 10 | Hawaii | |
| 2 | Lānaʻi | 9 | Hawaii |
| Te Fiti | 9 | Motunui | |
| 3 | Aogashima | 8 | Izu Islands |
| Kaho'olawe | 8 | Hawaii | |
| Kasai | 8 | Kanto | |
| 4 | Paletwa | 7 | Burma |
| Puku | 7 | Rakiura | |
| Tamatoa | 7 | Motunui | |
| 5 | Alawa | 6 | Daydream Island |
| Maui | 6 | Hawaii | |
| Pāru | 6 | Sinnoh | |
| Waewae | 6 | Rakiura | |
| 6 | Hīrōzu | 5 | Johto |
| Hōkū | 5 | All Stars | |
| Hōseki | 5 | Sinnoh | |
| Mikura-jima | 5 | Izu Islands | |
| Mizu | 5 | Kanto | |
| Padawa | 5 | Maré Island | |
| Saffron | 5 | Super Smash Brothers | |
| Whetu | 5 | All Stars | |
| 7 | Akunin | 4 | Johto |
| Hoshi | 4 | All Stars | |
| Humaliwo | 4 | Malibu | |
| Kyaal | 4 | All Stars | |
| Moloka'i | 4 | Hawaii | |
| Okkan | 4 | Burma | |
| Roro | 4 | Rakiura | |
| Sōfu-iwa | 4 | Izu Islands | |
| Sumatra | 4 | Sunda Islands | |
| Tairiku | 4 | Hoenn | |
| Te Kā | 4 | Motunui | |
| Tuvipora | 4 | Bedarra Island | |
| 8 | Bago | 3 | Burma |
| Cap | 3 | Barcelona | |
| Escondido | 3 | Malibu | |
| Heroes | 3 | Islands of Adventure | |
| La Roche | 3 | Maré Island | |
| Manbarra | 3 | Daydream Island | |
| Manhattan | 3 | Unova | |
| Myōjin-shō | 3 | Izu Islands | |
| Nautilus | 3 | Bedarra Island | |
| Nejire | 3 | Sinnoh | |
| Pescador | 3 | Malibu | |
| Shinbyu | 3 | Burma | |
| Villains | 3 | Islands of Adventure | |
| 9 | Bahari | 2 | Open Ocean |
| Casal | 2 | Barcelona | |
| Condal | 2 | Barcelona | |
| Ēteru | 2 | Hoenn | |
| Iloa | 2 | Niue | |
| Kaiyō | 2 | Hoenn | |
| Kaua'i | 2 | Hawaii | |
| Miti | 2 | Niue | |
| 10 | Bronx | 1 | Unova |
| Civilians | 1 | Islands of Adventure | |
| Jagara | 1 | Daydream Island | |
| Java | 1 | Sunda Islands | |
| Kakamora | 1 | Motunui | |
| Ngaka | 1 | Rakiura | |
| Okinawa | 1 | Midway Atoll | |
| Pandanus | 1 | Bedarra Island | |
| Porites | 1 | Bedarra Island | |
| Sagara | 1 | Open Ocean |